3 January 2025 by Benedict Smith

Supreme Court hands down key judgment on costs in Inheritance Act claims

Background to the claim

Mr Hirachand died leaving a widow, their daughter and their son.  Under Mr Hirachand’s will, his widow received his entire estate.  The daughter filed a claim against the estate under the Inheritance Act, arguing that due to her severe health issue and financial hardship, the disposition of the estate by the will failed to make reasonable financial provision for her.

Due to her straitened finances, the daughter had entered into a Conditional Fee Agreement (‘CFA’), often referred to as a ‘no win no fee’ agreement, with her solicitors.  As is standard in such agreements, the CFA included a ‘Success Fee’ payable if the daughter’s claim succeeded.  It was the status of this success fee that was the subject of the Supreme Court judgment.

The High Court and Court of Appeal judgments

The High Court concluded that the will did not make reasonable financial provision for the daughter and awarded her £138,918 – crucially, including a contribution of £16,750 within that sum towards the Success Fee.  The Judge found that the Success Fee formed part of the daughter’s financial needs, as the daughter had no choice but to pay the Success Fee to her solicitors.

The widow appealed on the basis that allowing a contribution towards the daughter’s Success Fee was an error in law.  The Court of Appeal upheld the High Court’s decision, finding that considering the Success Fee and factoring it into an award was within the court’s discretion.

The widow appealed again to the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court judgment

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and ruled that a Success Fee cannot be recovered as part of an award under the Inheritance Act.

It was noted that Inheritance Act claims are subject to the Civil Procedure Rules (‘CPR’), where costs are dealt with under a costs order that is separate from any substantive award.  Attention was also drawn to the statutory prohibition on successful parties recovering Success Fees from the opposing party pursuant to the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 (‘CLSA 1990’).  The Supreme Court found that allowing Success Fees to be included in substantive awards would result in conflict with the policy objectives underpinning the CLSA 1990 and the CPR.  By allowing the appeal, the Supreme Court keeps the balance intended by the costs regime with costs being considered after the substantive claim is resolved.

Implications of Hirachand v Hirachand

The Supreme Court’s ruling will have a significant impact upon claims under the Inheritance Act, for potential claimants and defendants alike.  After a lengthy spell of uncertainty, the position regarding CFAs and Success Fees is now confirmed as being what it was previously, namely that Success Fees cannot be included within a substantive award made by the Court.

Claimants relying on CFAs will need to factor in payment of the Success Fee from any award they received from the Court, which may lead to an increase in alternative funding for claims under the Inheritance Act by claimants with limited means.  Some experts have speculated that the decision may see a decrease in the number of Inheritance Act claims, as claimants with more speculative claims do not take on the potential risk.  However, others have voiced concerns that a failure to allow contributions to Success Fees will lead to inflated claims to cover those costs and hamper settlement negotiations.  The Supreme Court decision will provide some reassurance to executors and beneficiaries that substantive awards will not include provision for Success Fees and will therefore be lower.

Conclusion

The Supreme Court judgment provides certainty to the issue of CFAs within Inheritance Act claims.  The fact that it took some 11 months for the Supreme Court to hand down its judgment underlines both how important the issue was and how complex such disputes can be.

The number of contentious probate disputes generally and Inheritance Act claims specifically have increased in recent years.  This matter emphasises the need for individuals, whether disappointed beneficiaries or those defending a claim, to obtain quality legal advice.  Bolt Burdon is available to provide guidance on these intricate areas of law, as well as providing options for alternative funding where appropriate.

Should you have any questions regarding Inheritance Act claims or contentious probate disputes generally, please contact our Disputed Wills and Trusts team.

19 December 2024 by Bolt Burdon LLP

Domestic abuse does not stop at Christmas

For many, Christmas is a time for celebration and togetherness, however, for others, it can be quite the opposite, leaving...

19 December 2024 by Bolt Burdon LLP

Christmas arrangements for separated parents

The festive period is a time many people spend with their closest family and friends. Understandably, for separated parents this...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.