Signup To Our Weekly e-News
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.
This summer, in the landmark case of Standish v Standish, the Supreme Court agreed to the largest reduction of a financial award in the UK – from £45 million to £25 million. In doing so, the Court provided clear guidance on how to assess whether an asset is considered matrimonial or non-matrimonial in divorce proceedings.
Background
The husband had a successful career in financial services, accumulating most of his wealth prior to his relationship with his wife. The couple married in 2005, with the husband then retiring two years later. Throughout the course of their relationship, the wife had been a homemaker.
In 2017, the husband transferred around £80 million into the wife’s sole name as part of a tax planning arrangement; with the wife agreeing to put the money into trust for the benefit of their children. The wife failed to do this, retained the funds and commenced divorce proceedings in April 2020.
With £80 million being in the wife’s sole name, it was treated as ‘separate’ property. However, since she agreed to share this sum with her husband, she claimed it should be considered ‘matrimonialised’, and thus shared equally between the parties, irrespective of its pre-marital nature. The husband contested this, arguing for it to be treated as non-matrimonial due to its pre-martial status.
At the first hearing in 2022, the net value of the assets held by the parties stood at around £130 million. The first instance judge concluded that the £80 million had ‘matrimonialised’ and thus he awarded a 40:60 split, leaving the wife £45 million.
The wife appealed this decision, arguing her entitlement was 50:50; with the husband cross-appealing and arguing that his wife was entitled to less due to non-matrimonial assets being included in the £45 million. The Court of Appeal dismissed the wife’s appeal, granting the husband’s appeal on the basis that the £80m did not in fact ‘matrimonialise’, reducing the wife’s settlement to £25 million. The wife appealed to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court’s Judgment
The Supreme Court unanimously rejected the wife’s appeal, setting out five key principles on how to approach non-matrimonial assets and the sharing principle:-
1. Matrimonial or Non-Matrimonial?
Assets that compromise the fruits of marriage are considered matrimonial assets and the ownership of the asset at the time of the divorce will not be considered conclusive. Conversely, pre-marital wealth, gifts, or inheritance, are generally considered non-matrimonial.
2. The Sharing Principle Only Applies to Matrimonial Property
The sharing principle does not extend to non-matrimonial property unless there are claims based on needs and/or compensation.
3. Equal Division is Still the Stating Point for Matrimonial Property
The point reconfirmed that the starting point for sharing matrimonial property should be equal division. Parties can depart from this position if necessary but this is fact specific.
4. Non-matrimonial property can become matrimonialised
The new test for matrimonialisation is two-fold:
Simply transferring an asset into the other’s name is not enough.
5. Tax planning does not amount to intention to share.
Transferring assets between spouses to minimise tax does not mean that the asset becomes matrimonialised without compelling evidence to the contrary.
Key Takeaway – Document Clearly to Protect Your Assets
If you want to ringfence non-matrimonial assets, it is imperative to be able to evidence your intention to do so. Documenting your tax planning decisions is therefore a must. Furthermore, entering into a pre or post nuptial agreement also carries significant weight when providing evidence of intention as regards matrimonial vs non-matrimonial property. With the proper advice, setting out your intentions clearly will minimise potential disputes in the event of a divorce.
For more information about protecting your assets in the event of separation, please contact Kiran Reyat in our Family team to discuss further.
It may come as a surprise, but the law governing wills has remained largely unchanged since the Victorian era. Thankfully,...
Angela Rayner, Labour’s Deputy Leader and Housing Minister, has resigned amid allegations of underpaying Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) by...
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.