10 October 2025 by Benedict Smith

Llama Drama and Lines of Sight

While the law surrounding Wills may be subject to future reform (see our previous enews about this), two recent High Court cases provide a clear reminder that the current legal requirements remain firmly in place and must be followed precisely. Whether it’s a Will signed under lockdown restrictions or one written decades ago, these cases show how easily legal uncertainty can arise when a will is outdated or improperly executed.

Case one: Coady V Coady – Execution Formalities

The first case concerned a Will executed in April 2020, during the early stages of the Covid-19 pandemic. In response to the crisis, temporary legislation had been introduced to permit the remote witnessing of Wills via video conferencing. This was intended to offer flexibility where social distancing measures made traditional in-person witnessing impractical.

In Coady v Coady, the testator signed her Will while seated inside her open back door, with two neighbours observing from a table in her garden. Although this arrangement was clearly designed to comply with pandemic restrictions, the Court found that the execution of the Will did not meet the requirements of section 9 of the Wills Act 1837.

Specifically:

  • The testator did not sign her Will in the presence of both witnesses.
  • The witnesses did not witness the Will in the testator’s presence.

As a result, the court held that the Will was invalid, and the estate passed according to an earlier Will.

This case is one of the first to directly address the legal consequences of a pandemic-era execution, and it serves as a cautionary tale about the risks of informal or improvised witnessing procedures even under extraordinary circumstances.

Case two: British Camelids Ltd v Brook Hospital – Review Your Will

The second case involved a dispute over a £1.9 million estate left to six charities, each working for the benefit of animals. The Will, however, had been drafted in 1994 some 28 years before the testator passed away.

During that time, several of the named charities had either changed names, merged with other organisations, or ceased to exist altogether. British Camelids Ltd, the charitable arm of the British Llama and Alpaca Association, argued that three of the charities no longer existed as described, and that one had never existed in the form stated. They claimed that the gifts to these charities should therefore fail, leaving a larger share of the estate to the remaining identifiable charities, including themselves.

The High Court rejected this argument. The judge held that as long as the charitable purpose of the organisations continued, under a new name or through a successor body the gifts should be honoured. The estate was therefore divided as the testator had originally intended.

This case not only attracted public attention due to its unusual facts (and the involvement of llamas and donkeys) but also highlighted the potential pitfalls of failing to update a Will over a long period. A simple revision to reflect current organisational structures might have prevented the dispute entirely.

Key Takeaways

These two cases reinforce some essential principles for anyone preparing or reviewing a Will:

  • Formalities must be followed: The legal requirements for witnessing and executing a Will remain strict. Failure to comply can result in a Will being declared invalid, even if the testator’s intentions were clear.
  • Regular reviews are essential: Wills should be revisited periodically, especially when circumstances change. This includes changes in family structure, finances, or the status of beneficiaries (particularly charities).
  • Legal advice is invaluable: Professional guidance can help ensure your Will stands up to scrutiny and reflects your true intentions, even many years into the future.

How we can help

Our experienced Private Wealth team, headed by Helen Beach, are available to assist you with your estate planning and to help you prepare or update your Will with confidence.  Should you have a query regarding a loved one’s Will, then you can also speak to our Disputed Wills & Trusts team, headed by Benedict Smith, for further guidance.

2 October 2025 by Stacy Lake

British Expats and the New Long-Term Resident Rules – Inheritance Tax Planning in 2025

A cocktail on the beach? Not so fast Picture a British expat stretched out on a beach in Barbados, cocktail...

8 October 2025 by Stacy Lake

INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE WEALTH SPOTLIGHT

INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE WEALTH SPOTLIGHT. EDITION 1 OCTOBER 2025 Read our Spotlight Bulletin here

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.