Signup To Our Weekly e-News
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.
The number of disputes regarding wills has increased in recent years. While some disputes arise from a feeling of dissatisfaction with the terms of the will, many are based upon concerns with the will itself. However, as set out below, the grounds for challenging a will are limited and can broadly be put into three groups: those based upon formalities and form; those based on the state of the testator; and those based upon alleged wrongdoing by another party.
Whilst the rules governing the formalities of will drafting and execution are well established, having been set out in the Wills Act 1837, it is not uncommon that challenges are made on the basis that the rules were not followed. There have also been recent cases of wills executed under the temporary rules for execution of wills put in place during the Covid 19 pandemic (as addressed in a previous E-News article).
In addition to failing to follow the formalities, proceedings can be issued to address the construction and correction of wills. The court may be asked to decide the question of what a testator intended where the wording of a will is ambiguous and may be asked to correct wills where the testator’s instructions were not carried out or where there has been a clerical error.
Many challenges are based upon or include a claim that the testator lacked the mental capacity required to make a will. The test applied to capacity was first set out in the case of Banks v Goodfellow as far back as 1870 and requires the testator to:
Whilst afflictions such as dementia, Alzheimer’s or even severe grief can render an individual incapable of validly making a will, it is important to note that capacity can fluctuate. The fact that an individual has been diagnosed with such an affliction does not automatically mean that they lacked capacity, rather the court would consider whether they met the four requirements of the test at the time that they executed the will.
A will may also be challenged on the grounds that the testator did not know and approve of its content. This is a distinct ground of challenge from capacity, often arising in specific circumstances that could raise doubts as to the testator’s knowledge, for instance where they are blind, illiterate or do not speak English.
In addition to challenges based upon formalities or the testator’s condition, it is also possible to challenge a will based upon the conduct of a third party. The most common of these challenges is on the ground of undue influence. Undue influence arises where a person applies pressure to the testator of such a degree that it destroys their freedom of choice, with the result that the will reflects the influencer’s wishes rather than the testator’s true intentions.
A related ground of challenge is fraudulent calumny. Unlike undue influence, the testator’s free will is not overborne; instead, their decision is shaped by false statements made by a third party, which mislead them into making a will based on untrue information. As summarised by LJ Levison in Re Edwards, this addresses a scenario where “A poisons the testator’s mind against B, who would otherwise be a natural beneficiary of the testator’s bounty, by casting dishonest aspersions on his character”.
Such challenges are the most serious, as they require deliberate deception and, as they potentially involve criminal behaviour, often lead to criminal prosecution. Given the seriousness of such an allegation, the burden of proof is higher for challenges of this nature.
Challenging a will is rarely straightforward. These cases are evidence-heavy, often turning on historic documents, medical records and witness accounts. They can be time-consuming, emotionally charged and legally complex, particularly where allegations such as undue influence or fraud are involved. Early, clear advice is essential to assess the strength of a claim and the proportionality of pursuing it.
Our Disputed Wills and Trusts team, led by Benedict Smith, combines technical expertise with a pragmatic and sensitive approach. We work closely with clients to investigate concerns thoroughly, evaluate the available evidence and provide clear guidance on the options available, whether that involves early resolution or robustly pursuing or defending proceedings.
Buying or selling property often means sharing financial information with your solicitor. While this can feel intrusive, these checks play...
Ahead of Sunday 8 March, colleagues in our firm came together to mark International Women’s Day and support the Give...
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.