Signup To Our Weekly e-News
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.
An area of the business rating system, long treated as routine, has now moved firmly into focus for the flexible office market. Following the decision in R (on the application of Warner) v Valuation Office Agency (the ‘Hackney Case’), the way business rates apply to serviced and co-working spaces is no longer a settled assumption. Instead, it is a live risk with potential material consequences for investors, owners (often referred to as operator in this context) and occupiers alike.
At the centre of the dispute is the Valuation Office Agency’s evolving approach to assessing flexible workspace. Traditionally, individual occupiers within serviced offices were treated as separate units for rating purposes, allowing them to benefit from Small Business Rates Relief, while the owner dealt with the administration of tax
The revised approach challenges that model. By treating an entire flex building as a single hereditament, the full rates liability shifts to the owner. In the Hackney Case, that interpretation resulted in a backdated liability of approximately £500,000, representing a 150% increase in liability from previous assessments that were already paid.
While the court has not yet ruled on the substance of the claim, granting permission for judicial review signals that the challenge is credible and worthy of full consideration. That alone introduces a new layer of uncertainty into a sector built on operational flexibility and predictable cost structures.
This is not simply a dispute about co-working desks and shared amenities. It raises a broader structural question: how does the business rates system respond to modern, owner-led real estate models?
Flexible occupation is no longer confined to offices. The same operational framework underpins sectors such as serviced laboratories, student accommodation and other multi-occupier environments. If a single-assessment approach becomes standard, its effects could extend well beyond flex offices into other asset classes.
In practice, concentrating liability at owner level does not remove the cost; it simply redistributes it. Increased rates exposure is likely to be reflected in pricing, ultimately affecting small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), start-ups and growth businesses that rely on flexible space to scale.
This issue is no longer a technical point confined to rating specialists. It is becoming a core commercial consideration for all parties involved in flexible workspace, from investors and landlords to owners and occupiers.
Where business rates liabilities increase materially, owner margins are likely to come under pressure. This can weaken covenant strength, reduce rent cover, and place strain on the sustainability of management agreements. For landlords and investors, this raises concerns around income reliability and the durability of underlying cash flows.
Although liability may sit with the owner, increased costs are unlikely to be absorbed entirely at that level. In practice, they are likely to be reflected in higher licence fees or service charges. This directly affects SMEs, start-ups and corporate occupiers relying on flexible space, potentially reducing affordability and demand.
Business rates treatment is moving firmly into the spotlight during transactions. Investors and lenders will need to scrutinise rating assumptions, historic assessments and the risk of reclassification with greater rigour as part of acquisition and financing processes.
More broadly, the case exposes a growing mismatch between traditional rating frameworks and modern real estate models. The existing system was not designed for highly serviced, flexible, multi-occupier environments, yet these models are now an established and expanding part of the commercial property market.
There is also a wider economic consideration. Flexible workspace plays a key role in supporting business formation, innovation and growth. Any structural increase in occupancy costs risks dampening demand, particularly among smaller and scaling businesses that depend on flexibility.
The outcome of the judicial review will be closely watched, but the immediate significance lies in the uncertainty it creates.
Business rates are emerging as a variable capable of materially influencing performance, pricing and strategy across the flexible real estate sector.
For investors, landlords, owners and occupiers alike, this is no longer a peripheral issue, but one that warrants close and ongoing attention.
The evolving business rates landscape is creating increased uncertainty across the flexible real estate sector. We work with asset managers and commercial landlords to help them understand the impact of this and manage their portfolios accordingly.
Please do not hesitate to contact our specialised Commercial Real Estate team, led by Artan Llabjani.
As many landlords, tenants and property professionals already know, the Renters’ Rights Act 2025 (“RRA 2025”) came into force on...
Probate claims in England and Wales have risen to a record high. One possible explanation is a growing perception that...
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.