Signup To Our Weekly e-News
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.
The Building Safety Act 2022 allows flat owners i.e. tenants to shift the cost of certain remediation works relating to building safety defects to another party (usually to the original developer or the landlord). One of the costs which can be shifted is those associated with a waking watch – the deployment of personnel to patrol a building and raise the alarm if a fire breaks out.
According to a national survey by the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government the median cost of a waking watch is £11,361 per building per month, while the mean cost in England is closer to £17,897. These costs continue to rise.
The Government is aware of these rising costs and has announced a new £62 million fund for fire alarm installations intended to replace waking watch measures. The only problem is that this was announced under the Starmer Labour government and as of the date of this article no further update has been given.
As waking watch costs continue to rise, what does this mean for tenants who are asked to bear them?
Responsibility for waking watch costs depends on the circumstances, including the building’s ownership, the terms of the leases, relevant legal duties, and the cause of the fire safety concern. Each building is different and each approach requires careful consideration.
For the most part, tenants are finding themselves at the receiving end of these costs by way of service charges demanded by landlord and/or agents. However, landlords and agents need to be careful and not automatically assume that tenants should be left to bear the costs.
Section 120 of the Building Safety Act 2022 provides that landlords can take relevant steps to prevent relevant defects from arising. The scope as to which “relevant steps” available to landlords has widened to include interim remedial measures, including the installation of waking watch models.
A string of decisions from the tribunals has urged caution. These decisions have resulted in Remediation Contribution Orders being made so that landlords and/or agents are left to contribute to the costs of waking watch measures. Landlords need to remember that any costs incurred as a result of their own failure to comply with their statutory or regulatory obligations means that they may not be able to pass these to tenants.
The key takeaway – waking watch costs should not automatically be assumed to be the tenants’ responsibility.
A waking watch model may be necessary to protect residents, but it should not become a substitute for timely, consistent, and effective fire safety improvements.
Questions arise as to liability of costs especially where these costs continue to accumulate without a clear end date, where remedial works are unreasonably delayed, or where a suitable and more cost-effective alternative, such as a temporary common fire alarm system, could be implemented.
Whether charges are unreasonable (and result in landlords being made to contribute to waking watch models) will depend on the facts, the applicable legal framework, and the evidence supporting the expenditure.
Waking watch arrangements have become a vital tool for building safety but the financial burden needs careful scrutiny preferably in advance of the costs being incurred to prevent disagreements and disputes arising.
For landlord and managing agents, it is imperative that they conduct a regular careful review of arrangements, timely pursue permanent solutions and keep costs transparent and proportionate.
For tenants facing mounting charges, early legal advice can clarify who is liable, whether sums demanded are reasonable, and what options may be available to challenge them.
If you need advice navigating the Building Safety Act 2022, want to know more about your rights, or understand more about your obligations please contact Joshua De Luna or a member of the Real Estate Disputes team.
Many people automatically think of appointing a spouse, child, or close friend as their attorney under a Lasting Power of...
Employment Tribunal Time Limits: What’s Changed and What Does it Mean For Your Business? From 1 October 2026, the time...
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.