25 April 2025 by Benedict Smith

Adult children claims and conduct defenses under the Inheritance Act 1975

Earlier in the year, the case of Howe v Howe made headlines after a court awarded an adult child £125,000 from a parent’s estate after being written out of the will. The child had been branded “lazy” and “useless” by the parent, but the court did not consider the allegations of poor conduct sufficient to prevent an award of financial provision from the estate being made.

Historically, claims by adult children under the Inheritance (Provision for Children and Dependants) Act 1975 (‘the 1975 Act’) were looked upon unfavourably by the courts, who did not wish to impinge upon testamentary freedom. In the lead authority of Re Coventry, it was emphasised that an independent adult child would fail in their claim without establishing something “beyond the mere fact of a blood relationship, some reason why it can be said that, in the circumstances, it is unreasonable that no or no greater provision was in fact made.”

The landscape appeared to change with the Supreme Court decision of Illot v Blue Cross, where an adult child of the deceased was awarded financial provision from an estranged parent’s estate. Whilst the court approved the approach that “something more” than the fact of being a child of the deceased was required; it rejected the suggestion that this must be some form of moral claim. Since then, the number of claims by adult children under the 1975 Act has increased, along with other probate disputes such as will challenges.

In response to claims by adult children under the 1975 Act, defences are often put forward on the grounds of poor conduct by the claimant. However, as with the recent Howe v Howe case, such defences struggle to gain traction with the courts. As noted in Illot v Blue Cross, it is not the purpose of the Act to reward good behaviour or punish poor behaviour. It is notable that in Land v Land and  Meeking v Meeking, two tragic cases where the claimant was criminally responsible for the deceased’s death, awards were still made to the claimant under the 1975 Act.

Whilst the recent cases could be interpreted as a ‘sea change’ in attitudes to claims by adult children under the 1975 Act, such a conclusion appears upon closer inspection to be flawed. Whilst adult claims have succeeded, all those claimants have been able to demonstrate “something more” than the mere fact of a parent/child relationship, be it a disability, an estrangement or financial need that would render gifts made by a will unreasonable. The case of Miles v Shearer, which came after Illot v Blue Cross was decided, evidences that the courts will not interfere with an individual’s right to decide how to distribute their estate without good reason.

The recent Supreme Court decision of Hirachand v Hirachand should also be borne in mind when considering adult claims under the 1975 Act. As noted in our previous article, the court confirmed that success fees under a conditional fee agreement, otherwise known as a ‘no win no fee’ arrangement, cannot be recovered as part of an award in a 1975 Act claim. This is likely to have a significant impact on the number of claimants pursuing spurious claims against an estate in the hope of using costs pressures to obtain a settlement.

The law relating to contentious probate and inheritance disputes remains complex and cases will be decided upon their own facts.  If you feel that you have been unreasonably treated in a will or by the rules of intestacy, or if you are facing a claim against an estate that you are either a beneficiary or administrator of, then it is vital that you take independent legal advice. Should you wish to discuss a claim under the 1975 Act or contentious probate disputes generally, please contact our Disputed Wills and Trusts team.

11 April 2025 by Bolt Burdon LLP

Inheritance Tax on Pensions – Could Inheritance Tax Insurance protect your legacy?

One of the standout measures announced by Rachel Reeves in her Autumn 2024 budget, was the proposal to make most...

16 April 2025 by Melanie Carroll

UNDERTAKINGS – YOUR WORD IS YOUR BOND?

The Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal (SDT) have fined a solicitor with 50 years’ experience recently for breaching an undertaking in a...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.