20 March 2026 by Heather Cowley & Sophie Georgiou

Employers Beware: The Appeal Stage Can Make or Break a Dismissal

A recent decision from the Employment Appeal Tribunal is a timely reminder that even where you have strong medical evidence and a fair reason for dismissal, mishandling the appeal process can still render the dismissal unfair.

We are highlighting this case because the facts are not unusual. In fact, they reflect the kind of practical and administrative issues many employers face – cancelled meetings, internal confusion over who should hear an appeal, delays, and assumptions that the employee will revert if they wish to proceed.

What happened in Mirline v DHL Services Ltd [2026]?

A recent employment tribunal decision examined the dismissal of Ernest Milrine, who had worked for DHL as an HGV driver since 2013. After going off sick in January 2020 with anxiety, depression and vertigo-related conditions, his driving licence was revoked for a year. Occupational Health assessments concluded there was no realistic prospect of him returning to driving or alternative duties, and he was dismissed on medical capability grounds in June 2022.

Mr. Milrine appealed his dismissal, but the appeal process was beset by problems. The original manager declined to hear it, a replacement was appointed, one hearing was postponed due to lack of representation, and another was cancelled on the day because the manager was unwell. HR left it to Mr. Milrine to decide how to proceed, and the appeal ultimately never took place. He instead began Early Conciliation through Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (ACAS), mistakenly believing this prevented him from continuing his internal appeal.

Although the Employment Tribunal initially rejected his unfair dismissal claim, the Employment Appeal Tribunal later found the dismissal unfair due to serious procedural failings in the appeal stage.

The Decision Held 

The Employment Appeal Tribunal found that the dismissal was unfair, not because the employer lacked medical evidence or a potentially fair reason, but because of serious procedural failings in the way the internal appeal was handled.

In reaching that decision, the EAT reinforced several important principles that employers should note:

  • An appeal is not optional. It is a normal and essential part of a fair dismissal process.
  • When assessing whether a dismissal is fair, a Tribunal looks at the entire process, including the internal appeal stage.
  • An internal appeal is not only relevant where it is capable of curing an earlier defect or otherwise making a difference to the outcome.
  • If an employer fails to offer an appeal, or conducts one in a procedurally flawed way, this can turn an otherwise fair dismissal into an unfair one.
  • However, a dismissal will not automatically be unfair an employer fails to offer an appeal or provides an appeal that is procedurally defective. It is simply one of many factors for the Tribunal to consider.

Points to Note

What can employers learn from this case?

  • Employers should offer a fair internal appeal. Failure to do so may render an otherwise fair process unfair, which can result in successful claims against you. The appeal stage is not a formality. It is a critical safeguard.
  • The importance of following up. Just because an employee has not come back to you in relation to an appeal hearing (as was the case here), does not mean it will be fair not to take any steps towards arranging an appeal. Instead, employers should ensure the matter is followed up with the employee.
  • Communication is key. Having an employee turn up to your premises expecting a formal appeal hearing to take place, when the person who is supposed to be hearing the appeal is not available, is not helpful to anyone.
  • ACAS Early Conciliation is not an excuse not to arrange an appeal. If an employee starts Early Conciliation, it remains important to complete your internal procedure. If the employee goes on to start an Employment Tribunal claim, the fact that you have completed a fair process may support your defence.

If your business requires employment law advice, please do not hesitate to get in touch with our employment team led by Heather Cowley.

5 March 2026 by Benedict Smith

Where there’s a (suspicious) will there’s a way (to challenge it)

The number of disputes regarding wills has increased in recent years. While some disputes arise from a feeling of dissatisfaction...

13 March 2026 by Edward Green

The Draft Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill: The Next Chapter for Leasehold Property

The 22nd May 2024 might not spring to mind as a particularly significant date for most. It was the date...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.