21 February 2025 by Jessica Egan

MOTHrepresentation in Property Transactions: Lessons from the High Court on Misrepresentation

The case of Patarkatsishvili & Hunyak v Woodward-Fisher involved the sale of a £32.5 million mansion in west London, where the seller (Woodward- Fisher) failed to disclose a severe moth infestation to the buyers (Patarkatsishvili), leading the court to find that the seller had made fraudulent misrepresentations in their pre-contract responses.

 What Is Misrepresentation?

Misrepresentation occurs when; (a) when one party makes a false statement to another party, (b) the parties enter into a contract, and (c) one party relies on the false statement in order to enter into the contract. There are three types of misrepresentation in English law:

  • Fraudulent Misrepresentation – When a seller knowingly makes a false statement or makes it recklessly without caring whether it is true or false. This was found to be the situation in the above case, as the seller had received damning pest control reports prior to completing precontract enquiries, but still stated they were unaware of any infestation.
  • Negligent Misrepresentation – When a party makes a false statement without taking reasonable steps to verify its accuracy.
  • Innocent Misrepresentation – When a seller makes a false statement but had reasonable grounds to believe it was true.

The key issue in this case was the seller’s response to pre-contract enquiries. The seller denied knowledge of any vermin infestation…despite clear evidence to the contrary!

 Why Pre-Contract Enquiries Matter

During a property transaction, buyers rely on the seller’s responses to pre-contract enquiries—standard questions used to uncover issues that might affect the property’s value or suitability. If a seller provides false or misleading information in these responses, they may be held liable for misrepresentation.

The Court found that Mr Woodward-Fisher’s failure to disclose the moth infestation amounted to fraudulent misrepresentation. Mr Woodward-Fisher’s argument was that moths were not “vermin”. However, the Court vehemently rejected this argument.

 Legal Consequences of Misrepresentation

The buyers were awarded substantial damages, including:

  • Repayment of the purchase price, minus a deduction to account for the time they had resided at the property.
  • Reimbursement of Stamp Duty Land Tax and pest eradication costs.
  • £15,000 for personal belongings damaged by the infestation.

The damages awarded demonstrate that fraudulent misrepresentation can lead to a significant financial award for the buyer (and burden for the seller!), which can include compensation for all losses suffered as a result of the misrepresentation.

 Key Takeaways for Buyers and Sellers when considering misrepresentation

For sellers, this case is a clear warning: all material defects known to the seller should be disclosed honestly in pre-contract enquiries. Failure to do so can lead to serious legal and financial consequences.

For buyers, while pre-contract enquiries provide some protection, it is advisable to, where possible, conduct independent surveys and inspections to identify potential issues before completing a transaction.

This case reinforces the importance of transparency and good faith in property transactions. Sellers must provide accurate information, and buyers must carry out due diligence to protect their interests.

At Bolt Burdon, we strive to provide bold, bespoke, and brilliant legal expertise. If you would like some advice about misrepresentation, please contact Jessica Egan from our Real Estate Dispute team. For advice on selling or buying property generally, please contact our Residential Real Estate team.

7 February 2025 by Heather Cowley & Stacy Lake

Family Investment Companies 101: The Basics You Need to Know

In this article, our International Private Wealth and Corporate & Commercial team provide an overview of Family Investment Companies (FICs),...

13 February 2025 by Bolt Burdon LLP

A New Era for Leaseholders: Removal of the Two-Year Rule

Since 2017, the leasehold sector has been the focus of intense government inquiries, Law Commission reports, and legislative changes, all...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.