6 June 2025 by Isa Celkupa

Navigating Commercial Lease Assignments and Subletting

In the current market, we are seeing struggling tenants entering into discussions with their landlords regarding the future of their premises. In market standard leases, assignment and subletting are allowed. These mechanisms offer much-needed flexibility, enabling tenants to adapt to changing business circumstances, and landlords to maintain continuity in occupancy and rental income.

What is Assignment and Subletting?

An assignment refers to the transfer of the tenant’s (the assignor) entire leasehold interest to an incoming third party (the assignee). The assignee then assumes the assignor’s lease obligations and becomes directly liable to the landlord.

For leases granted on or after 1 January 1996, assignors are automatically released from future lease obligations and covenants at assignment. This can be problematic for landlords as there is no assurance that the lease covenants will be complied with by the incoming tenant.

To mitigate this, landlords often require the assignor to enter into an Authorised Guarantee Agreement (AGA). An AGA makes the assignor guarantee the assignee’s performance under the lease and allows the landlord to pursue a claim against them if the assignee defaults.

Subletting, by contrast, allows a tenant (the sublessor) to retain their lease by granting a sublease over part or all of the property to a third party (the subtenant). This creates a layered relationship where the subtenant is liable to the sublessor, who remains liable to the landlord.

Importantly, if the sublessor sublets the entire premises and ceases to occupy any part for business purposes, they may forfeit their security of tenure under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954. This means that the tenant loses the right to remain in the property once the lease has expired.

Restrictions and Requirements

Most commercial leases contain a clause which restricts assignment or subletting without the landlord’s prior written consent. In such cases, s. 19(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 implies a term that consent must not be unreasonably withheld.

While ‘unreasonably withheld’ is rather ambiguous and fact-specific, landlords may usually only withhold consent for genuine and objective reasons pertaining to the lease itself (e.g. the proposed assignee’s financial standing), as opposed to solely commercial motivations (e.g. seeking a higher rent from the incoming party).

What Landlords Need to Know

  • Review the Lease Terms: Understand your rights around consent, AGAs, and any conditions attached to assignment or subletting.
  • Due Diligence on Incoming Parties: Always assess the financial standing, business history, and intended use of the premises by an assignee or subtenant.
  • Use of AGAs: Properly drafted AGAs can protect landlords from losses if an assignee defaults. In order to be valid, AGAs must be:
    • in writing;
    • signed by the assignor (as guarantor); and
    • entered into as a lawful condition of the landlord’s consent to the assignment.
  • Retention of Control: Consent clauses and conditions can help landlords maintain control over who occupies their premises and ensure compliance with the lease terms.

What Tenants Need to Know

  • Check the Lease for Restrictions: Most leases will limit your ability to assign or sublet without consent—be aware of these clauses.
  • Understand the Legal Impact: Assigning the lease means transferring all obligations to the assignee; subletting creates ongoing responsibilities.
  • Be Aware of Security of Tenure Risks: If subletting the entire property, make sure you don’t inadvertently lose your right to renew the lease.
  • Prepare for Financial Scrutiny: Whether assigning or subletting, be prepared for the landlord to vet the proposed party thoroughly.
  • AGA Implications: Be mindful that even after assignment, an AGA may keep you on the hook if the new tenant fails to perform.

Navigating an assignment or subletting of a lease, whether you are the landlord or the tenant, requires a clear understanding of the legal framework and practical implications so you must seek advice before signing on the dotted line.  As experts in commercial leases, please contact Artan Llabjani or Bradley Ali for help.

15 May 2025 by Bolt Burdon LLP

MENTAL HEALTH WEEK 2025: WHAT EVERY EMPLOYER NEEDS TO KNOW

As we reach the end of Mental Health Awareness Week 2025, it’s a timely reminder that mental health is not...

22 May 2025 by Bolt Burdon LLP

READY, SET, SELL: STEPS TO ENSURE A SUCCESSFUL BUSINESS SALE (PART 1)

Selling your business is a major milestone, requiring careful planning. In this first article of our Ready, Set, Sell series,...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.