11 July 2025 by Bolt Burdon LLP

Non-Court Dispute Resolution in Family Cases

From 29th April 2024, changes were made to the Family Procedure Rules (FPR), placing greater focus on parties engaging with Non-Court Dispute Resolution (NCDR) from the outset. The aim is to facilitate an early resolution of financial claims on divorce and private law children matters away from the courtroom. Prior to this update, parties had to attend the Mediation Information and Assessment Meeting (MIAM) before issuing Court proceedings (unless an exemption applied). The key change is that the definition of “non-court dispute resolution” is widened to now include mediation, arbitration, evaluation through a neutral third party (such as the Financial Dispute Resolution process) and collaborative law.

There have also been changes to the rules relating to MIAMs. MIAM providers must now advise on the principles, processes and potential benefits of all forms of dispute resolution (not only mediation) and indicate to attendees which form may be the most suitable and why/how to proceed. The circumstances in which an exemption from a MIAM can be claimed have been limited too. Given this, what are the options when it comes to NCDR which could be best for you and your family?

 Mediation

Mediation is a voluntary process which involves a neutral third party (trained mediator) who will oversee disputes to ensure they are carried out in a non-confrontational manner. The mediator facilitates discussions either face-to-face or remotely and can assist in finding solutions that are acceptable to both parties. Mediations pose as a method which can empower couples to negotiate and make their own decisions with the view of reaching an agreement that is best for their family.

Early Neutral Evaluation (ENE)

An ENE is an alternative dispute resolution is a process where a neutral third party, likely a solicitor, barrister or retired judge, provides an impartial assessment of the likely outcome of a case. The neutral third party will be appointed with the agreement of both parties, at their joint expense.

The process of an ENE is designed to assist parties in resolving disputes by offering realistic evaluations of their positions and what they would order if they were deciding the matter at trial. This alternative dispute resolution approach encourages settlement and reduces financial and emotional repercussions of litigation; with the purpose of aiding parties to take this advice on board and consider the indications when negotiating to ensure realistic outcomes.

Private Financial Dispute Resolution

A FDR is a pivotal stage in family law proceedings in England and Wales, especially in financial remedy cases. It is judge-led and designed to assist separating parties in solving financial disputes through negotiations and discussions.

The FDR is usually the second hearing during traditional Court proceedings at which the Judge gives an indication as to how they consider the case could be settled and which is intended to assist the parties reaching an agreement at Court to conclude the proceedings.

A private FDR mirrors that process, however, it is possible to arrange a private FDR during existing financial remedy proceedings or before an application is ever made to the Court. Neither party is legally bound by the indication, but it hopefully allows the terms of a settlement to be agreed either on the day of the private FDR or soon after with the help of their lawyers. Each party is represented by their own solicitor or barrister during the Private FDR.

Arbitration

Arbitration involves the appointment of an impartial arbitrator to assist in resolving a dispute. The decision of the arbitrator will be binding on both parties and can assist parties in achieving the certainty of a final decision. Arbitration offers a flexible approach for couples as it can take place at a chosen time and venue that suits the parties.

Collaborative practice

Collaborative practice is designed to help separating couples resolve issues such as finances and child arrangements in a constructive and respectful way. Each party will be represented by a collaboratively trained solicitor and then sign a participation agreement, which includes a disqualification clause preventing the lawyers from representing the parties in court if the process breaks down or if the parties don’t reach an agreement. This process typically involves face-to-face meetings where both parties and their lawyers collaboratively reach a mutually acceptable resolution. At this time, parties will have access to other experts during the process like accountants, therapists etc.

Each party will be represented by a collaboratively trained solicitor. The solicitors work together with the parties to negotiate and reach a settlement with the commitment that neither of them will resort to making an application to the Court.  The process involves a series of meetings at which both parties and their solicitors are present to discuss and resolve issues. Parties may have access to other experts during the process like accountants, therapists etc. If they do not reach an agreement through this process, the solicitors acting are precluded from representing them in court proceedings.

How could we help?

If you are considering a separation or divorce, it is worth exploring the options to find a resolution that works for you and your family, ideally without the intervention of the Court. It is also worth noting the potential financial implications of failing to engage in NCDR options as the Court does have the power to adjourn ongoing family proceedings to allow couples to consider NCDR options. Our Family team, headed by Kiran Reyat, can offer expert legal advice with an emotional touch when aiding on the matters mentioned above to provide the best possible outcome for you and your family.

 

26 June 2025 by Victoria Blanshard

Burial Disputes

Burial disputes are extremely emotive and often arise in estates where there is a background of family divisions and rifts....

3 July 2025 by Joshua De Luna

Update: The Renters’ Rights Bill faces delay in reaching royal assent

Update: The Renters’ Rights Bill faces delay in reaching royal assent  In England alone, the private rented sector accounts for...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.