19 July 2024 by Bolt Burdon LLP

Proctor v Proctor – A reminder to agree all relevant terms in your partnership agreement

The Court of Appeal recently had the opportunity to consider an aspect of partnership law, the outcome of which serves as a reminder why it is a good idea to have a partnership agreement tailored to your specific needs.

Am I even in partnership?

A partnership is formed under the Partnership Act 1890 (the “Act”) where two or more persons are “carrying on business in common with a view of profit”. A partnership can therefore come into existence without a formal agreement, without filing or registering any documents, and without any other formalities.  As a result, business partners may be unaware that they are in a legally binding partnership.

The Act sets out various provisions that apply to partnerships.  In many cases, these can be overridden by the terms of a partnership agreement.  However, in the absence of an agreement, the default provisions under the Act will apply.

These default provisions may not be suitable for how the partners wish to run their business and failing to exclude or modify sections of the Act could have undesirable outcomes for the parties. The partnership agreement, while largely dependent on the particular business to which it relates, will usually include provisions relating to profit sharing, duration, termination, exit of partners and how losses will be divided.

Proctor v Proctor

The case of Proctor v Proctor [2024] EWCA Civ 324 serves as a reminder to thoughtfully consider the needs of the partnership.  Failure to do so may lead to the court stepping in, which may result in unintended outcomes.

This case involved a family partnership, formed to continue a farming business carried on by the father on family-owned land in Yorkshire.  While there was a partnership agreement in place with each of the partners being entitled to a one-quarter share of the profits, it did not deal with what would happen when a partner unilaterally resigned.

Following discussions about restructuring the partnership’s indebtedness, the daughter wrote to her father to resign from the partnership. This was accepted by the other partners but there was no discussion of the financial consequences.

In 2014, following the death of her parents, the daughter brought a claim against the other partners – her brothers. She claimed that she was entitled to a quarter share of the partnership, valued as at the date of her resignation. The High Court found in her favour and, ultimately, the Court of Appeal agreed.

In this matter the parties engaged in two full trials and two appeals, no doubt spending a very substantial amount in legal fees on the way.  If they had had a clear and professionally drafted partnership agreement in place before the daughter’s resignation, all that could have been avoided.

If you need a partnership agreement drawn up, or need advice in relation to your existing partnership agreement, please don’t hesitate to contact our expert Corporate & Commercial team.

 

 

 

 

 

 

12 July 2024 by Melanie Carroll

Source of funds and source of wealth checks – what are they and why are they necessary?

The Money Laundering Regulations 2017 (MLR) impose obligations to check source of funds and wealth when acting for clients in...

14 July 2024 by Louise Dawson

We’re a certified green small business

We’re a certified green small business. After a rigorous assessment, we’ve achieved ‘Green Small Business Certified’ status. As a Green...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.