Signup To Our Weekly e-News
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.
Service charge disputes are among the most common issues in residential buildings. Disagreements frequently arise over the necessity, scope, quality or cost of works, charges and expenses. The interpretation of the leases, the landlord and tenant regulations and the way that the courts apply the rules may be complex, and the parties may end up incurring legal costs that are sometimes disproportionate to the value of the sums in dispute.
As a general rule, legal costs incurred before proceedings are issued, are not recoverable from the opposing party even if that party succeeds, subject to limited exceptions.
We will focus on legal costs incurred in proceedings before the County Court or the First-Tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) (“FTT”). Since service charge disputes may be determined in the FTT or the County Court, the ability to recover legal costs will be a key issue to consider when deciding if and where proceedings should be issued. Understanding the costs position from the outset helps parties to assess the merits of a claim and make informed commercial decisions.
In service charge disputes, the parties are:
The prospects of recovering legal costs depend on which party starts the court proceedings.
Where service charges are not paid, landlords will normally pursue recovery actions arising from breaches of the lease. The main options are forfeiture proceedings, following the required court determination of breach or County Court debt recovery proceedings.
A landlord may be able to recover its legal costs in a service charge dispute in two main ways:
Depending on the circumstances, the provisions of the lease and the procedure chosen, the landlord may be able to recover all or part of its legal costs.
Leaseholders may challenge service charges under section 27A of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 on grounds that the charges are not payable under the lease, are unreasonable, were not properly incurred or that they have not been validly demanded.
Unlike landlords, tenants do not normally have contractual rights under the lease to recover their legal costs. In most cases, their only route to recovery is through a costs order, which is unlikely unless the landlord has acted unreasonably, as discussed above.
Leaseholders do, however, benefit from an important statutory protection. Under section 20C of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, the FTT may prevent the landlord from recovering its legal costs through the service charge. Whilst this does not enable tenants to recover their own costs, it can prevent them from indirectly funding the landlord’s legal expenses.
Where multiple leaseholders are affected, collective action may also reduce individual costs and strengthen the overall position before the FTT.
When considering a service charge dispute, the key question is not only whether a claim is likely to succeed, but also whether the costs of pursuing it are proportionate and recoverable.
For landlords, key considerations include the choice of forum (the FTT or the County Court), the availability of costs recovery provisions in the lease and the proportionality of the anticipated costs.
For leaseholders, important considerations include the possibility of collective action and the availability of a section 20C order.
At Bolt Burdon, we are experts in service charge disputes. We advise both landlords and tenants on costs exposure, recovery prospects and litigation strategy from the outset, helping them to make informed decisions before getting involved in a service charge dispute. Please do not hesitate to reach out to our Residential Real Estate Disputes team who would be delighted to assist.
From April 2027, many families could face unexpected inheritance tax (IHT) bills as pensions become part of an estate for...
Cohabiting couples are the fastest-growing family type in the UK. According to Office for National Statistics data, the number of...
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.