2 October 2026 by Desara Pali

Surrogacy and Legal Parenthood: What Intended Parents Need to Know

The Current Legal Framework

Surrogacy is the process by which a child is carried through pregnancy by a person with the intention that, at birth, the child and legal parenthood of the child is transferred to another person(s).

Surrogacy arrangements in England and Wales are regulated by the Surrogacy Arrangements Act 1985. The practice of commercial surrogacy is prohibited, with it being a criminal offence for any person to initiate or advertise a surrogacy arrangement on a commercial basis, or receive a payment which is not a ‘reasonable’ expense.

However, altruistic surrogacy is lawful, and intended parents may pay or reimburse expenses, subject to the court’s scrutiny when considering a parental order.

Parental responsibility is determined by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act (HFEA) 2008.  As it currently stands, the surrogate mother is automatically the legal mother at birth, regardless of whether they are genetically related to the child or not.  A parental order is then required by the intended parent(s) for legal parenthood to be transferred to them..

Parental Orders

The parental order application is a lengthy process which first requires the intended parent(s) to meet several criteria:-

  1. They must have a genetic link to the child – at least one of their gametes was used;
  2. Unless they are a single parent, they must be either married, civil partners or living as partners in an enduring family relationship;
  3. They must have attained the age of 18;
  4. The application must be made within 6 months of the child being born;
  5. The child must reside with them in England or Wales at the time of the application;
  6. They must have the free and unconditional consent from the surrogate to make the application; and
  7. They must have only paid reasonable expenses to the surrogate.

The court appoints a parental order reporter, usually from Cafcass, to investigate the circumstances and report on the child’s welfare. The child’s lifelong welfare is the court’s paramount consideration. Until the order is made, the intended parents may not have full authority to make decisions about the child, and the surrogate remains a legal parent even if the child has lived with the intended parents since birth.

Why Reform Has Been Proposed

The Law Commission has made proposals for reform for several years, but the government has advised that it is not a legislative priority.  There is no call for the decriminalisation of commercial surrogacy arrangements, as there is an ethical and moral obligation to prevent England/Wales from having a commercial surrogacy market and for children to be treated like commodities.

However, it can be argued that the current law on parental responsibility and surrogacy is out of sync with modern society and scientific developments. It is contradictory for the surrogate, and their spouse or civil partner (where applicable), to retain parental responsibility for the child until the parental order is granted, particularly as this process can take several months and the child is living with the intended parent(s) rather than the surrogate. Further, the requirement for the intended parent(s) to have a genetic link with the child is also contradictory when the surrogate inherits parental responsibility automatically and may not be genetically related to the child at all.

As a result, individuals have resorted to entering international surrogacy arrangements in countries such as the US, Colombia, Mexico and Nigeria, where commercial surrogacy is legal and intended parent(s) are immediately registered on the child’s birth certificate. They are still required to apply for a parental consent order in England/Wales to recognise their legal parenthood, but the Court is increasingly dispensing with the criteria for surrogate consent as most of the time, it is an anonymous surrogate who cannot be traced or contacted. According to The Guardian’s article, there were 1,000 children born by surrogates in 2025, with only 150 born in the UK and 850 born internationally.  Arguably, the government’s prolonged delay in implementing much-needed reform in this area of law serves only to perpetuate the risks of exploitation.

How We Can Help

Our experienced Family Law team provides clear, practical advice on aspects of surrogacy and parenthood. Whether you are considering a surrogacy arrangement, navigating the legal process, or seeking guidance on your rights and responsibilities, we can help you understand the legal framework and support you at every stage.

18 September 2026 by Sally Caldicott

The Limits of Generosity: Attorneys’ Powers to Gift under LPAs

A Lasting Power of Attorney for Property & Financial Affairs (LPA) provides Attorneys with a wide range of powers. However,...

25 September 2026 by Maham Dar

Navigating the Help to Buy Equity Loan Maze: From Existing Loans to Future Proposals

The Help to Buy Equity Loan was a government scheme introduced in 2013. It ran for many years, allowing thousands...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.