Signup To Our Weekly e-News
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.
In our article from 17 March 2022, we considered the ability of landlords to collect rent arrears from commercial tenants who had been affected by the coronavirus regulations.
We also considered the Government’s bill on the Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Act 2022 (“the Act”), which came into force on 25 March 2022. The Act places temporary restrictions on landlords’ ability to recover rent from commercial tenants. It encourages landlords and tenants to resolve rent disputes through arbitration. The Act will be in place until 24 September 2022.
In this update, we consider the decision made in the first case referred to arbitration under the Act.
Revisiting “Protected Rent Debt”
Under the Act, a business is deemed to be adversely affected by coronavirus if the business or its premises were subject to a closure requirement. The Act also defines a “protected period” which, broadly speaking, is the period the business was subject to the closure requirement.
Where a tenant has rent arrears that relate to the “protected period”, these will be classified as “protected rent debt”.
What is a “Closure Requirement”?
For tenancies in England, this is an obligation to close:
from 2pm on 21 March 2020 and ending at or before 11.55pm on 18 July 2021. For tenancies in Wales, the end of the relevant period is 6am on 7 August 2021.
Signet Trading Limited and (1) Fprop Offices (Nominee) 4 Limited and (2) Fprop Offices (Nominee) 5 Limited
While the Act appears to encourage business tenants to establish their businesses again and come back from the effects of the pandemic, the decision in the recent case involving Signet Trading Limited (which owns leading retailers H Samuel and Ernest Jones) suggests otherwise.
The tenant was seeking relief from rent arrears in the sum of £448,043.04 in relation to its headquarters (which are office premises rather than retail premises). It argued that the headquarters were subject to the closure requirement since they supported the retail business. Directors and staff involved in the buying and selling of merchandise had been working from there. During the pandemic, the office closed with almost all the staff working from home but two staff members were still working at the office. The tenant’s argument was dismissed on the basis that the office premises did not fall within the closure requirement because the staff were able to work there. Therefore, the rent arrears were not regarded as a “protected rent debt”. The office premises were only indirectly affected by the closure requirement of the retail premises.
Government guidance indicates that the Act does not ignore any impact on the landlord’s solvency. Therefore, it seems that a balanced approach will be considered when deciding whether relief is available to tenants who are in arrears. While the aim of the Act was to encourage tenants to bounce back after the pandemic, a strict interpretation of the Act is unlikely to have this effect. The decision will be welcomed by landlords, as other non-retail tenants will be deterred from bringing claims for relief under this Act.
For further information about how the Act affects you, please contact our Commercial Real Estate team.
Non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) or confidentiality agreements are often used when an employee leaves their job or, indeed, to keep embarrassing...
Background Edward Smith died on 24 January 2016, aged 97, leaving a Will dated 11 June 2013 (‘the 2013 Will’)....
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.