13 September 2024 by Bolt Burdon LLP

The Glamorous World of Share Buybacks in Private Companies

Imagine you’re a shareholder in a private company.  Perhaps you invested because it was your best friend’s pet project or maybe you wanted a slice of that tech startup that sounded like the next big thing.

A few years down the road, you might be thinking “I need my money back” or perhaps the company has too many shareholders for comfort.

Enter the share buyback – a corporate mechanism designed to rescue both company and shareholders from potential headaches.  But what exactly is it?  And why would anyone bother?

What is a share buyback?

In simple terms, a share buyback happens when a company buys back shares in itself from shareholders.  Those shares are then cancelled or held in treasury, reducing the total number of shares in circulation.  This has the effect of increasing the percentages of shares held by the remaining shareholders.  Imagine the company as a pie.  With fewer slices (shares), each remaining slice is a bigger piece of what’s left and potentially more valuable.

Why would a private company want to buy back shares?

There are a few reasons why a private company might want to go the buyback route:

  1. The breakup – perhaps one of the shareholders wants out. Instead of having to sell their shares to some stranger (and potentially introducing a wild card to the company), the company itself can buy back the shares.
  2. Control freaks – buybacks can help the remaining shareholders consolidate control by reducing the number of voting shares in circulation. Fewer shareholders mean fewer opinions and, potentially, fewer boardroom squabbles.
  3. Optimising the balance sheet – if the company has excess cash lying around with nothing better to invest in, it can make sense to buy back shares. This can improve certain financial metrics, make the company look more attractive on paper, or simply prevent money from gathering dust.
  4. The shareholder clean-up – maybe the company has too many shareholders, diluting decision-making or leading to administrative headaches. By buying back shares, the company can tidy things up.

How does it work? The basic steps under English law

Share buybacks in private companies aren’t something you can just decided over a Friday pint.  There are rules.  Companies in England are governed by the Companies Act 2006, which lays out a neat process for how to go about buying back shares.  Here’s a high-level breakdown:

  1. Check the articles of association – the first thing a company needs to do is check its articles of association. That’s the company’s rulebook.  Some companies might need to amend these rules before a buyback can proceed.
  2. Shareholders’ approval – this isn’t something the board can just rubber-stamp. For most private companies, an ordinary resolution is required.  This means the holders of more than 50% of the shares need to vote in favour of the buyback (not including the person whose shares are to be bought).
  3. Fund the buyback – a company can’t just hand over Monopoly money. It generally needs to have enough ‘distributable profits’ to pay for the shares.  If it’s feeling bold, it can also finance the buyback from capital (but this is a considerably more complicated process).
  4. The buyback contract – there needs to be a buyback contract, detailing how many shares are being bought, at what price and when.
  5. Companies House filings – once the deal is done, there’s yet more paperwork. The company must file a return with Companies House, notifying the registrar of the buyback.  There may also be stamp duty to pay.
  6. Cancellation of shares – finally, those bought-back shares are cancelled, effectively reducing the company’s issued share capital (or, a little less frequently in our experience, they may be held in treasury, ready to be sold on again in future to a new shareholder).

The not-so-fun part: restrictions and pitfalls

While the idea of buying back shares might sound like the corporate equivalent of a spring clean, it’s not without complications.  For starters, buybacks can only be done under strict conditions.  If the company doesn’t follow the rules, the buyback can be invalidated, which could create legal issues down the line.  There are also tax implications to consider (quite apart from the stamp duty referred to above) – and so shareholders may find themselves facing unexpected tax bills if the buyback isn’t structured properly.

In short, a share buyback is a useful (though admittedly slightly bureaucratic) tool for a private company to regain control, clean up its shareholder base or provide an exit for investors.  In the right hands, it can be a savvy financial manoeuvre.

If you’re considering a share buyback, please don’t hesitate to contact our expert Corporate & Commercial team.

30 August 2024 by Bolt Burdon LLP

Buying and selling a property should be an exciting time – agreed!

However, the process can also be a stressful one as there are so many elements beyond your control which can...

6 September 2024 by Bolt Burdon LLP

THE NEW DUTY TO PREVENT SEXUAL HARASSMENT – ARE EMPLOYERS DOING ENOUGH?

As set out in our April Employment Law Update, the Worker Protection (Amendment of Equality Act 2010) Act 2023 comes...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.