26 September 2025 by Isa Celkupa

The Only Way Is Up? Maybe Not for Commercial Rent Reviews

Buried within the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill, introduced on 10 July 2025, is a proposal to ban upwards-only rent review clauses (UORRs) in new commercial leases. The draft legislation, introduced without prior industry consultation, could significantly impact both landlords and tenants, creating challenges and opportunities for each side.

What Is Being Proposed?

Under Schedule 31 of the Bill, any new commercial or business lease must allow rent to move both upwards and downwards. This means UORRs, a long-standing feature of UK commercial leases, can no longer be created and would be effectively banned.

Implications for Landlords

For landlords, UORRs provided a degree of financial stability by guaranteeing that rents would not fall. This mechanism has been vital in supporting property valuations, cash flow stability, and investment confidence. The removal of UORRs introduces income volatility, especially in weaker markets where rents may be falling.

To adapt, landlords might:

  • Increase initial rents to hedge against future downward adjustments.
  • Use stepped or index-linked rent clauses (still permitted under the Bill), which provide fixed or inflation-adjusted increases.
  • Opt for shorter leases or exclude leases from 1954 Act protections, reducing long-term commitments.
  • Reassess valuations to incorporate falling rents, potentially accepting higher yields or lower capital values.

Larger landlords with diversified portfolios may be better placed to absorb these changes, but smaller landlords who are reliant on consistent income may struggle.

Implications for Tenants

For tenants, the possibility of downward rent adjustments offers a significant respite. This change could prevent tenants from being locked into overinflated rents that don’t reflect market conditions, improving business resilience in tougher times when operating costs are already at historic highs.

However, tenants should also prepare for indirect consequences. Landlords may:

  • Increase initial rents to compensate for the risk of downward adjustments.
  • Offer fewer incentives, such as reduced rent-free periods, or tighten lease terms.
  • Seek to shorten lease terms or exclude security of tenure rights under the 1954 Act, potentially creating more complex lease negotiations.

 Conclusion

The proposed ban on UORRs represents a substantial challenge to how risk is managed in commercial leases. While tenants could benefit from greater flexibility, landlords face greater income uncertainty. Both sides will need to adapt quickly and closely monitor legislative progress. As the Bill advances, it’s crucial for both landlords and tenants to adjust their expectations and strategies to prepare for the evolving market landscape.

How can we help?

If you are a commercial landlord or tenant, our expert Commercial Real Estate team is on hand with practical and pragmatic advice. For advice, please contact Artan Llabjani or Bradley Ali to discuss your options.

 

12 September 2025 by Abrar Omran

Angela Rayner, SDLT and Trusts – the High Cost of Assumptions

Angela Rayner, Labour’s Deputy Leader and Housing Minister, has resigned amid allegations of underpaying Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) by...

19 September 2025 by Kiran Reyat

Marriage and Money – Are My Assets Mine or Ours

This summer, in the landmark case of Standish v Standish, the Supreme Court agreed to the largest reduction of a...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.