Signup To Our Weekly e-News
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.
The recent High Court decision in Thirsk v Thirsk & Ors has provided useful discussion of various issues relating to claims by the surviving spouse under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 (‘the 1975 Act’). As well as dealing with the ‘divorce cross-check’ in depth, the judgment addresses long-term relationships, the needs of the surviving spouse and the distinction of matrimonial and non-matrimonial property.
The Deceased sadly passed away in April 2022, survived by a spouse, Sarah, and a son from a previous relationship, Henry. Although they had been in a cohabiting relationship for 19 years, the Deceased and Sarah had only been married for 1 year prior to his death.
The Deceased’s estate was worth around £26 million and consisted for the most part of farmland. Under the terms of the Deceased’s Will, Sarah was bequeathed a lump sum of £5 million and the right to remain in their marital home for the remainder of her life. The balance of the estate, which constituted the significant majority in value terms, was left to Henry.
Sarah issued a claim under the 1975 Act on the grounds that the Will failed to provide reasonable financial provision for her. One factor relied upon in bringing the action was a claim by Sarah that the couple’s lavish spending exceeded £700,000 annually and that she expected to enjoy this lifestyle for years to come.
The court considered various issues arising under the 1975 Act, including:
Although the period of marriage was short, the court treated both the 19 year cohabitation period and the marriage period as relevant when considering the length of the relationship.
The factors the court consider under section 3 of the 1975 Act include the ‘divorce cross-check’ and “have regard to the provision which the applicant might reasonably have expected to receive if…the marriage, instead of being terminated by death, had been terminated by a divorce order”.
In completing the cross-check the court and in line with recent judgments in family matters including the Supreme Court decision in Standish v Standish, the court drew a distinction between those assets that formed part of the marriage and were matrimonial, and those assets that the Deceased acquired prior to the relationship with Sarah. The court found that the majority of the Deceased’s assets were non-matrimonial and did not include these when deciding what to award Sarah.
The court gave consideration to the fact that the Deceased wished Henry to inherit the majority of the estate in order to continue the businesses run from the properties: the court noted and seemingly gave consideration to the Deceased’s desire to limit the impact of any award to Sarah on the Deceased’s desire “in as limited a way as was conversant with fairness”.
The court found Sarah’s claims regarding the couple’s levels of spending and her income claimed to be “overstated”. The court also considered that, given the age difference between Sarah and the Deceased, reasonable financial provision would not require maintenance of the current living standard indefinitely but indicated Sarah could “find a way to earn a modest income over the next two decades to supplement what she has”.
The court did, however, agree that a life interest in the matrimonial home was not sufficient. In order to ensure Sarah received reasonable financial provision, she was awarded the property outright.
Although Sarah was ultimately awarded an increased share of the estate, and notwithstanding that all 1975 Act claims will turn on their own facts, this case could undermine previously commonly held misconceptions regarding the inherent strength of spousal claims.
The divorce cross check had, incorrectly, been seen in some quarters as ensuring a surviving spouse a baseline figure of 50% of the estate. This misapprehension (which runs counter to the wording of the 1975 Act) was based upon a strict application of the sharing principle in matrimonial awards. The court were explicit in confirming that the divorce cross-check is only one factor to be considered.
The court also indicated that, rather than creating a lifelong dependency on the estate to maintain an existing lifestyle, reasonable financial provision from an estate should look to assist the surviving spouse’s transition to independence. With younger claimants this could see a significant shift in approaches to awards under the 1975 Act.
The different treatment of pre-matrimonial assets, in line with decision in the family courts, also indicates a potential shift in the factors the court will consider. This is, however, balanced by the recognition in this matter of the lengthy pre-marriage cohabitation period as being part of the marriage period.
Should you be involved in a contentious probate matter and wish to discuss either the costs consequences or the matter generally, please contact our Disputed Wills and Trusts team.
Employment Tribunal Time Limits: What’s Changed and What Does it Mean For Your Business? From 1 October 2026, the time...
The Building Safety Act 2022 allows flat owners i.e. tenants to shift the cost of certain remediation works relating to...
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.