6 December 2024 by Bolt Burdon LLP

Security of Tenure – what is it and what are the prospects for reform?

What is Security of Tenure?

Security of Tenure refers to the right for business tenants in England and Wales to automatically remain in occupation of their rented premises beyond the expiry of their lease. This right comes from the Landlord & Tenant Act 1954 (the “Act”).

The Act was introduced to strike a fairer balance between the landlord and tenant in business premises. Any lease which is protected is referred to as “inside the Act”. There are some types of tenancy that cannot be protected by the Act. For example, fixed term tenancies not exceeding six months, services tenancies (connected to employment e.g. a security guard’s flat), mining leases, agricultural tenancies (which have their own regime of statutory protection) and tenancies at will, which are a special type of tenancy that can be terminated at any time.

The parties to a lease can choose to exclude the lease from the protection of the Act, i.e. to make the lease “outside the Act”, by following a special procedure before the lease is granted. This involves making either a simple declaration (with a 14-day cooling off period) or, if the parties cannot wait 14 days, the tenant can provide a statutory declaration and then proceed straight to completion of the lease.

Recent Consultation on possible reform

Last month, the Law Commission published the first consultation report entitled Business Tenancies: The Right to Renew. This paper explored alternative models of security of tenure available to the Government. In brief, they included:

  • mandatory security of tenure;
  • no statutory security of tenure;
  • contracting-in to security of tenure; and
  • leaving things as they are (the current regime).

The Law Commission also commissioned a survey alongside the consultation to assess what proportion of commercial leases are currently contracted out of the Act to gain more insight into the scope of the Act and how it impacts the market. Responses to the consultation are expected by mid-February 2025 and a further consultation is expected thereafter before any final report is published. The Commission indicated that strong evidence supporting reform would be required before any changes would be made to the status quo, so we surmise it is unlikely any major or controversial reforms will be implemented in this parliament. That being said, lawyers and practitioners would benefit from some improvements to the general processes governing how leases are currently contracted out of the Act. This could be as simple as allowing declarations to be given or sworn digitally.

If you have any queries or you’re not sure whether your lease has Security of Tenure, do not hesitate to contact our expert Commercial Real Estate and Development team.

29 November 2024 by Louise Dawson

WE’RE WALKING THE TALK WITH B CORP!

The last 12 months have seen much change at Bolt Burdon, culminating in the launch of our new five-year business...

4 December 2024 by Benedict Smith

Assisted Dying – What can we expect next?

The House of Commons passed the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill through its second reading last week.  Whilst...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.