16 April 2025 by Melanie Carroll

UNDERTAKINGS – YOUR WORD IS YOUR BOND?

The Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal (SDT) have fined a solicitor with 50 years’ experience recently for breaching an undertaking in a property deal.  But what are undertakings, why do they exist, what can go wrong and what do clients need to know?

In a recent SDT case, the solicitor argued that he had not given an undertaking because he had not specifically used the word undertaking. The SDT did not agree with him and confirmed that just because the words undertake or undertaking had not been used, did not mean that one had not been given. The categorisation of the statement was unimportant. The solicitor was fined and barred from acting for 18 months as a sole practitioner.

What is an undertaking?

The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) defines an undertaking as: –

“a statement, given orally or in writing, whether it includes the word ‘undertake’ or ‘undertaking’, to someone who reasonably places reliance on it, that you or a third party will do something or cause something to be done, or refrain from doing something”

In essence, an undertaking is a promise made by a solicitor – and one they must stick to. It’s arguable that a ‘thumbs up’ emoji in answer to a request for information, could be construed as an undertaking! 👍🏼

Why do they exist?

Undertakings are a fundamental part of legal practice and, in some areas, such as conveyancing and litigation, are essential in enabling deals to be done. They are the cornerstone that allow cases to proceed smoothly, efficiently, and expeditiously.

Clients expect that any solicitor providing an undertaking, not only understands what the undertaking means, but will ensure that it is fulfilled.

If an undertaking is breached, then this can be enforced through the court over ‘officers of the court’.  The SRA and SDT can also take disciplinary action. The financial penalties can be harsh – and the reputational damage irreparable.

The fine handed down by the SDT in the case mentioned, demonstrates that professional misconduct is taken very seriously by our professional regulator – and so it should be.

What can go wrong?

Undertakings must be carefully drafted to ensure that there are no ambiguities, that it’s clear what needs to be done, by whom, and when, and with a clear method to measure the results. If there are discrepancies, an undertaking will be construed in favour of the recipient as to what they thought would happen. An unclear undertaking can lead to a dispute, which can be stressful, and waste time and money for all involved.

Worse still is the scenario referenced at the start, which is that an undertaking is breached or broken. Fortunately, this does not happen very often because undertakings are a bedrock of the profession – and the consequences of failing to comply with an undertaking are so severe. However, if this happens, it is essential to act quickly to ensure that the case affected can proceed.

What do I need to know as a client?

If we need to give an undertaking on your matter, then we will discuss this with you, explain why this is necessary, and seek your authority to proceed. If the undertaking relates to payment of money, then we will ask you to let us have this amount first. If we receive an undertaking on your matter, we will scrutinise this to ensure that there are no discrepancies and check the status of the person giving the undertaking to guarantee that we can rely upon it. And we won’t ask for an undertaking, if it is not one that we would be prepared to give!

Ultimately, undertakings are vital to the smooth running of cases, and we will treat them with the respect they deserve.

We will use them to your advantage where appropriate, but ensure you’re fully always protected – you’re safe in our hands. If you are interested in discussing anything that has been mentioned in this article, please contact Melanie Carroll.

3 April 2025 by Stacy Lake

Case Study on Family Investment Companies

In our previous articles, we explored the benefits of a Family Investment Company (FIC) as a tax-efficient and flexible succession...

11 April 2025 by Bolt Burdon LLP

Inheritance Tax on Pensions – Could Inheritance Tax Insurance protect your legacy?

One of the standout measures announced by Rachel Reeves in her Autumn 2024 budget, was the proposal to make most...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.