Signup To Our Weekly e-News
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.
Burial disputes are extremely emotive and often arise in estates where there is a background of family divisions and rifts.
The power to deal with the deceased
No individual owns a body. However, certain people have the right to dispose of a body, and it is that individual who would also take possession of the body and therefore deal with the burial or other disposition of the body.
The default position is that the power to plan for the burial of the body rests with the Personal Representative (‘PR’). This is sometimes not appreciated by family members, as it may be assumed that a surviving spouse or offspring of the deceased would take control. Ascertaining who the PR is where the deceased died intestate (without a Will) can also lead to disputes, and the potential for disagreements between multiple PRs as to how the body should be dealt with are not uncommon issues.
The court’s approach
The courts have developed a framework to resolve disputes focusing on the factors such as the deceased’s wishes, requirements of the family and the need for the body to be disposed of with proper respect and without undue delay. In the case of Hartshorne v Gardner (2008) the court made clear that the considerations were ranked in importance as follows:
Steps to avoid disputes
Ensuring both that your Will is professionally drafted and that your wishes are made clear in the Will file, along with sharing the information with your family and friends are all important steps in avoiding a dispute. Confirming that your chosen executor(s) are aware of your wishes should also help. Whilst there is no guarantee that they will be followed, when the deceased’s wishes are known, the court will give them significant weighting. The matter of Anstey v Mundle (2016) is an example of this, a dispute where the deceased’s wish to be buried in Jamaica was upheld despite the executors and family members disagreeing.
What to do when faced with a burial dispute?
It is important to act quickly in burial disputes and the court has the power to grant injunctive relief as it did in the case of Otitoju v Onwordi (2023). In this case the court determined that the executors named in the Will were entitled to take possession and control of the deceased’s body even though the Will’s validity was contested. The courts are understandably reluctant to intervene where burial has already taken place.
Overall, burial disputes are decided on a case-by-case basis and the emotional background requires delicate and sensitive handling otherwise the costs and contention can spiral.
If you require any advice on burial disputes, please contact Victoria Blanshard in our Disputed Wills, Trusts & Estates team. Should you require advice on your own Will to ensure that your burial wishes are up to date, please contact Helen Beach in our Private Wealth team.
Pride Month is a time to celebrate LGBTQ+ identities—but also to reflect on the legal realities many LGBTQ+ individuals still...
For many LGBTQ+ individuals, planning for the future means navigating not just legal complexity, but also personal and cultural sensitivities....
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.