17 November 2026 by Martin Castellanos

Leaving Commercial Premises? Avoid Costly Dilapidations Surprises

The current commercial property market continues to present challenges for both landlords and tenants. Understanding the parties’ respective obligations at the end of a commercial lease is essential, as disputes can have significant and unexpected financial consequences where the landlord considers that the property has not been returned in the condition required by the lease.

Claims for dilapidations can involve substantial sums if the parties disagree about the tenant’s obligations or the landlord’s entitlement to recover costs. Seeking advice before a lease expires can help both landlords and tenants to avoid lengthy disputes and significant litigation costs.

What are Dilapidations?

Dilapidations refer to breaches of a tenant’s obligations under a commercial lease in relation to the condition of the property. These commonly include obligations to:

  1. Keep the property in good repair and condition,
  2. Redecorate it periodically and;
  3. Reinstate alterations carried out by the tenant by the end of the tenancy.

Landlords may identify these breaches and seek to recover the cost of remedying them or damages for the loss suffered as a result. Such claims are commonly pursued towards the end of a tenancy or immediately after its termination.

What Can Landlords Recover Through a Dilapidations Claim?

A landlord cannot necessarily recover the full cost of every item included in a schedule of dilapidations. Whilst the tenant may have breached its obligations, the landlord must establish that it has suffered a recoverable loss as a result.

Damages for dilapidations are governed by common law principles and Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 (LTA 1927). Under this section, damages for breaches of repairing obligations cannot exceed the diminution in the value of the landlord’s interest in the property attributable to those breaches.

For example, if the estimated cost of carrying out the necessary repairs is £100,000 but the reduction in the value of the landlord’s interest as a result of the disrepair is only £40,000, the landlord’s damages will generally be limited to £40,000. A diminution valuation may therefore be necessary to establish the extent of this cap and assess the landlord’s potential entitlement to damages.

The landlord’s intentions for the property after the tenancy ends may also impact the amount recoverable. If the landlord intends to undertake a substantial refurbishment or redevelopment, some of the repairs or redecoration may be unnecessary or superseded by the proposed works. This is known as the principle of supersession.

However, the existence of redevelopment plans does not automatically prevent a dilapidations claim. The position will depend on the nature of the tenant’s obligations, the works proposed and the evidence of the landlord’s intentions.

Landlords should therefore carefully consider the terms of the lease, the losses suffered and the potential application of the diminution in value cap and the principle of supersession before preparing and serving a schedule of dilapidations on the tenant.

How Should Tenants Respond to a Dilapidations Claim?

Receiving a schedule of dilapidations from the landlord does not mean that a tenant must automatically accept the works identified or pay the amount demanded.

Tenants should first review their lease and any relevant licences for alterations to establish the precise obligations they have agreed to comply with. They should also consider whether the alleged breaches are properly established, whether the works proposed by the landlord are necessary and whether the amounts claimed are reasonable. Legal advice should be obtained to assess the tenant’s contractual obligations and any potential grounds for challenging the claim.

Obtaining an independent assessment from a building surveyor can be particularly important when challenging the technical aspects and cost of the proposed works. This may also include assessing the diminution in value and whether any works have been superseded by the landlord’s intention to refurbish or redevelop the property.

How Can Dilapidations Disputes Be Resolved?

The Pre-Action Protocol for Claims for Damages in Relation to the Physical State of Commercial Property at the Termination of a Tenancy (the Dilapidations Protocol) encourages landlords and tenants to exchange relevant information and attempt to resolve disputes without court proceedings.

The Protocol generally requires:

  • A schedule of dilapidations and quantified demand from the landlord;
  • A formal response from the tenant; and
  • Consideration of settlement discussions and alternative dispute resolution methods, such as mediation.

Early engagement and appropriate professional advice can help narrow the issues in dispute and avoid unnecessary litigation costs.

How We Can Help

Dilapidations claims can involve complex questions of contractual interpretation, valuation and the assessment of damages. Whether you are a landlord seeking to recover dilapidations costs or a tenant challenging a substantial claim, obtaining legal advice at an early stage can help protect your position and avoid the costs associated with protracted litigation.

Our Real Estate Disputes team advises landlords and tenants on commercial dilapidations disputes, including the assessment of contractual liability, the evaluation of claims and potential defences, the negotiation of settlements and litigation where necessary.

30 October 2026 by Benedict Smith

Till Death Do Us Part: What Thirsk v Thirsk means for spousal inheritance claims

The recent High Court decision in Thirsk v Thirsk & Ors has provided useful discussion of various issues relating to...

6 November 2026 by Desara Pali

Adoption and Legal Parenthood: What Intended Parents Need to Know

Adoption is the legal creation of a parent-child relationship by court order (“Adoption Order”), treating the adoptee as if born...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.