8 August 2024 by Bolt Burdon LLP

High Court trust dispute over DNA involving £14.5 million estate

Last week, the High Court heard an inheritance dispute involving DNA evidence. It was claimed the DNA test proves one of the beneficiaries of a family trust is not a biological child of the deceased and therefore is not entitled to receive a share of the family business.

Background

Stuart Marcus, a successful entrepreneur, passed away in 2019 aged 86, leaving his toy-making business ‘Kitflix Swallow Group Ltd’, valued at £14.5 million. He had two sons, Edward and Jonathan, who both played roles in managing the business during Stuart’s lifetime.

Prior to his passing, Stuart set up a trust leaving 43% of his business assets ‘for the benefit of his children and remoter issue…and their spouses’.

Trial at Court

Jonathan has issued a claim in the High Court to challenge his brother’s entitlement to the trust on the basis that Edward is not Stuart’s biological child and therefore is not entitled to receive the trust proceeds as beneficiary.

Supposedly, Jonathan and Edward’s mother, Patricia, had an extra-marital affair with her former boyfriend, Sydney Glossop, and fell pregnant with Edward. Mr Glossop has now passed away.

It is understood that Patricia had revealed this information to Edward in 2010, although he now argues that she later retracted this statement. Jonathan discovered this information last year which led him to bring his claim, supported by evidence by way of a DNA test that proves he and Edward are half-siblings only. As such, he argues that Edward is not Stuart’s biological son.

Edward disputes the findings of the DNA test, claiming that, as Stuart’s DNA sample was not available, the results are inconclusive. His barrister argued in court that ‘sibling analysis’ is far less conclusive than ‘testing both parents against their alleged children’.

Edward has also asserted that his mother’s affair may have lasted more than one night and potentially went on over a period of years instead, thereby raising the possibility that Jonathan may in fact be Mr Glossop’s son, rather than Edward.

In response to this, Jonathan’s barrister argued that Patricia would not have told Edward that Mr Glossop was his father if it were not true, and he said it would be ‘vanishingly unlikely’ that she would have told Edward this if it was in fact Jonathan who was Mr Glossop’s son.

Edward has claimed that, even if the court accepts the DNA evidence, he is still entitled to benefit from the trust as Stuart’s step-son.

The judge has reserved judgment, to be given at a later date.

The position in law

In this case, the trust allocated the business assets to what is known as a class of beneficiaries (‘my children and remoter issue… and their spouses’) and therefore it is necessary to determine who falls within this description.

Generally, where a gift has been bequeathed to a child by way of wording such as ‘my child’ or ‘my children’, the reading will be construed to mean the settlor’s blood children only. However, depending on the context and admissible evidence, it could include step-children.

It is therefore vital that the wording of a trust is clear to reflect the settlor’s true intentions. Clear wording can avoid disputes, such as the above, from arising in the future.

If you would like advice on setting up a trust or a Will, please contact our Wealth and Estate Planning team or, if you are involved in an inheritance dispute, our Disputed Wills and Trusts team have the expertise to advise you at any stage of the dispute.

19 July 2024 by Bolt Burdon LLP

Proctor v Proctor – A reminder to agree all relevant terms in your partnership agreement

The Court of Appeal recently had the opportunity to consider an aspect of partnership law, the outcome of which serves...

2 August 2024 by Bolt Burdon LLP

What does the King’s Speech mean for developers?

The King’s Speech, which took place on 17 July, sets out the new government’s legislative agenda. In his speech, the King...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.