Signup To Our Weekly e-News
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.
The inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependents) Act 1975, often referred to as ‘the 1975 Act’ was aimed at providing protection, in the form of “reasonable financial provision” from the estate, for children and partners of the deceased who would otherwise face hardship were the estate to be administered according to the deceased’s will or the rules of intestacy.
Not without controversy when first presented, representing as it did a significant limiting of the testamentary freedom of individuals to deal with their estate how they deemed fit, the number of claims made under the 1975 Act has steadily increased over the years, and its deemed flaws subject to increased criticism and calls for reform.
The 1975 Act expanded the class of individuals who could apply for relief. Claims could be brought by a surviving spouse, a former spouse, any child (including adults), those treated as a child of the family and persons being maintained by the deceased. In later years, the list was expanded to include cohabitants who lived with the deceased and civil partners. As family structures have become more complex, so too has the scope of those entitled to bring a claim.
The 1975 Act also significantly widened the courts powers when determining what constitutes ‘reasonable financial provision’ for a successful claimant. The court may order lump sum or periodical payments from estate funds, the transfer or settlement of property, the acquisition of property for a claimant, or the creation of trusts dealing with estate assets.
These powers have been extended over time. They now include dealing with shares of jointly held property and lifetime dispositions designed to circumvent the Act, reflecting the courts broader role in ensuring fairness.
Initially the 1975 Act was interpreted narrowly, with the courts emphasising the need for testamentary freedom as much as applicant’s rights under the 1975 Act. However, over time, this approach has shifted, broadening the number of potentially successful claims.
The landmark cases of Lilleyman v Lilleyman in 2012, addressing spousal claims and the ‘divorce cross-check’, and Ilott v Blue Cross in 2017, confirming the eligibility of adult children bringing claims under the 1975 Act, significantly broadened the interpretation and application of the 1975 Act.
In recent years there has been a significant increase in both contentious probate claims generally and claims under the 1975 Act specifically. Some commentators point to the courts’ evolving interpretation of the Act as encouraging more claims.
However, others have focused on societal changes as being the catalyst for the increase in claims. Just as the 1975 Act was a reaction to changes in society, so the increase in mixed families and unmarried couples is pointed to as a factor in the increased number of claims. It also must be acknowledged that the relatively recent but significant increase in property prices makes claims more commercially viable.
The changes in society have also been used as grounds to seek reform of the 1975 Act. It is a common complaint that partners who choose not to marry are treated differently under the 1975 Act to married partners when it comes to deciding what constitutes reasonable financial provision.
Similarly, reform has been proposed on the basis that the 1975 Act does not reflect the reality of increased life expectancy and the corresponding increase in mixed marriages, with reform being preferred to the ongoing increase in claims.
Whether the 1975 Act will survive a further 50 years is open to debate. The recent Law Commission report suggesting changes to the Wills Act indicates a willingness to recognise certain laws governing testamentary rules as rapidly becoming outdated given changes to both technology and society.
It seems likely that if it does survive, the 1975 Act will do so in a different form to today’s legislation.
Until such time as changes are made, however, Bolt Burdon are here to assist and guide you through the law as it stands. If you feel that you have been unreasonably treated in a Will or by the rules of intestacy, or if you are facing a claim against an estate that you are either a beneficiary or administrator of, then it is vital that you take independent legal advice.
If you would like to discuss a claim under the 1975 Act or contentious probate disputes generally, please contact our Disputed Wills and Trusts team.
Expert evidence can play a decisive role in family court cases, particularly where allegations of parental alienation are made. A...
London has seen an increased amount of development over the last few years, particularly in the centre. As space becomes...
"*" indicates required fields
We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.