14 May 2026 by Benedict Smith

The Inheritance Drama Nobody Wants to Star In

Probate claims in England and Wales have risen to a record high. One possible explanation is a growing perception that such claims are more likely to succeed as judicial interpretation evolves (an issue we explored in a previous article). But anyone considering becoming involved in this type of dispute should keep firmly in mind the potentially serious financial consequences, as two recent cases demonstrate.

As a general rule, the successful party in litigation can expect to recover costs from the unsuccessful party. In contentious probate matters, however, that does not mean the court will automatically order those costs to be paid out of the estate.

A Reality TV Price Tag

The widely reported 1975 Act claim brought by Lonan O’Herlihy, who appeared in Made in Chelsea, offers a stark example of the costs consequences that can follow unsuccessful litigation. The claim raised a number of interesting issues, including an unsuccessful application under section 4 of the 1975 Act to bring the claim after the six-month deadline. But it was the aftermath that drew the headlines: the failed claim left the claimant facing a costs order in the region of £2m.

Keeping Up With the Costs

There was a similar outcome in a will dispute in which a costs judgment was handed down earlier this year. The case concerned a purported 2021 will which differed significantly from two earlier wills that had divided the estate broadly equally between the deceased’s children. Under the disputed will, the majority of an estate worth approximately £600,000 was left to one child, while the other two siblings were left just £250 each.

The court ultimately held that the will should be set aside because it had not been properly witnessed and because there was insufficient evidence that the deceased knew and approved of its contents. The judge also described the circumstances surrounding the instruction and execution of the 2021 will as “highly suspicious”.

A subsequent costs order left the unsuccessful party facing a substantial legal costs bill. The total costs covered by the order were well in excess of the reduced amount that party would receive from the estate after the claim.

Winning Can Still Be Costly

Costs consequences can affect successful litigants and even those who are not beneficiaries. Because probate disputes often involve multiple parties, overall legal costs can quickly escalate. Following the Supreme Court’s confirmation that ‘no win no fee’ arrangements cannot be included in costs awards in 1975 Act claims (as previously commented on), it is increasingly common for part of what a successful party receives from an estate to be used to meet legal costs—whether because the estate is ordered to bear some costs or because assessed costs leave a shortfall. Executors and personal representatives can also be exposed: in the disputed will case referred to above, the executor who defended the claim alongside the unsuccessful child was held jointly and severally liable for the costs.

Resolve Early, Preserve More

Most contentious probate disputes settle well before trial, and often before proceedings are even issued. That reflects a simple commercial reality: once likely legal costs are weighed against the value of the estate, litigation can quickly become disproportionate. There are also several forms of alternative dispute resolution (‘ADR’), including mediation and early neutral evaluation, which can resolve disputes more quickly and at lower cost than court proceedings. The potential costs protection that can come from making sensible settlement offers is another important factor that is too often overlooked.

Look Before You Jump

Some claims will still require the court’s involvement, but issuing or defending proceedings is always a significant step with potentially serious consequences for everyone involved. As the recent case law shows, anyone considering that course should take proper advice at an early stage and understand the possible outcomes before deciding how to proceed.

How we can help

If you are involved in a contentious probate dispute and would like advice on the potential costs implications or the matter more generally, please contact our Disputed Wills and Trusts team.

Our experienced disputed wills and trusts specialists are well placed to guide you through complex estate disputes and help you achieve a practical and effective resolution.

8 May 2026 by Joshua De Luna

The Building Safety Act Four Years On: Progress or Unfinished Business?

The tragedy of the Grenfell Tower fire in 2017 continues to loom large over London and the nation. Plans have...

12 May 2026 by Martin Castellanos

Renters’ Rights Act 2025: Notify Your Tenants by 31st May or Face the Penalty

As many landlords, tenants and property professionals already know, the Renters’ Rights Act 2025 (“RRA 2025”) came into force on...

Signup To Our Weekly e-News

"*" indicates required fields

We’ll never share your details with any third party in line with our privacy policy.